ETF Trend Following and Managed Futures
By David Kreinces, ETF PM (10/17/14 Updated)
Many leading consumer advocates in finance recommend strategic index investing to protect and grow your liquid investment assets long-term. However, when equity markets crashed in 2008, growth index portfolios fell between 15% and 42%. So, what’s the best way to enhance diversification beyond strategic indexing?
Over the past 27 years, trend-following strategies, tracked via the Systematic Index, have returned roughly 8% annually. This investment process has a proven ability to broaden diversification and to deliver gains when equity markets crash. For example, when the equity markets crashed in 2002 and 2008, the trend following index gained 12% and 18%, respectively.
Instead of trying to predict the future, these managers employ proprietary rule-sets that react to existing trends in the price and volatility of securities. In fact, trend following is now one of the largest strategies in the hedge fund marketplace.
Many investors have been unaware of trend following because it was only offered in complex investment products called “managed futures.” However, this past decade, the growth in exchange-traded funds (ETFs) has enabled innovative firms to provide ETF trend following.
Altegris (MFTAX) – Managed Futures Mutual Fund
The Altegris Managed Futures Strategy (MFTAX) is a mutual fund with over $250 million invested in a group of leading managed futures portfolio managers. This managed futures fund of funds has a trailing 3.8 year annualized return of -3.4%.
Systematic Index (SI) – Managed Futures Index
The Systematic Index (SI) tracks the performance of 482 systematic programs with aggregate investment assets well over $250 billion. This trend following index has a trailing 3.8 year annualized return of -1.4%.
AQR (AQMNX) – Managed Futures Mutual Fund
The AQR Managed Futures Strategy (AQMNX) is a mutual fund with over $6 billion in assets. AQR is one of the world’s largest managed futures portfolio managers and this fund has a trailing 3.8 year annualized return of 1.1%.
ETF PM (50/50 Portfolio) – Separate Account of ETFs
The ETF PM 50/50 Portfolio (50/50) is an ETF portfolio that combines strategic indexing with tactical trend following. Half the portfolio is passively indexed to the eMAC growth benchmark, and the other half rotates exposure between leading equity asset classes and cash. The trailing 3.8 year annualized return is 3.4%.
The Bottom Line
Trend following has underperformed passive indexing since 2009, but experienced investors know that trend following typically underperforms between brief periods of extraordinary outperformance. At ETF PM, we advise clients to employ a combination of ETF trend following and strategic indexing in order to maximize long-term performance.
While nobody can consistently predict which of these trend following strategies will perform best, they all present a good starting point for investors to enhance their diversification beyond strategic indexing.
David S. Kreinces is the Founder of ETF Portfolio Management (ETF PM), a revolutionary financial advisor specialized in investing with index funds and exchange-traded funds. He has over 20 years of professional investment experience in multiple asset classes and investment processes. He is an expert in trend following and successfully delivered gains in the crash of 2008. See www.etfpm.com and www.InvestableBenchmarks.com.